Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM) has been successfully applied to a wide variety of digital communications applications over the past several years and has been adopted as the wireless LAN standard.
Just what is OFDM, and what makes it better? To answer this question, we need to review some basic ideas about wireless telecommunications systems, and how OFDM fits into the overall picture.
In what follows, we will review the following concepts needed to understand OFDM; digital messages, carrier waves, modulation and multiplexing. Then we will explain OFDM and why it is used.
Wireless communications systems are used to send messages between two locations using radio waves which travel across free space. Messages of all types (voice, music, image, video, text) are usually converted to digital form and are represented as a stream of 1's and 0's called bits (binary digits). Voice messages can be represented by about 10,000 bits per second, CD quality music needs about 100,000 bits/sec, and TV quality video messages require about 1,000,000 bits per second, plus or minus. Text messages can be sent at any speed, depending on how long you are willing to wait.
Radio waves are electromagnetic waves used to carry a message over a distance. Thus radio waves are also called a carrier waves. A carrier wave looks like a sine wave, and moves like a train at the speed of light. The frequency of the carrier wave is the number of times per second that the wave train goes up and down and back up as it moves past you, and is measured in units of cycles per second or Hertz.
Carrier (electromagnetic) waves of different frequencies and wavelengths have different properties. For example, radio waves can travel through walls, but light waves cannot. Lower frequency waves tend to travel further, and can bend around corners. Higher frequency waves travel more or less only via line of sight. Thus certain parts of the radio spectrum are better suited for certain types of telecommunications. For indoor wireless communications through walls over a distance of several hundred feet, or outdoor communications over several miles mostly over line of sight with perhaps some trees in the way, carrier frequencies in the range of 1 to 5 GHz (gigahertz or billion cycles per second) are used.
Modulation is the process whereby a carrier wave of a particular frequency is modified or modulated by the message signal, so that the modulated carrier wave can be used to carry the message over a distance. For digital messages (a stream of 1's and 0's), there are three basic kinds of modulation:
Amplitude Shift Keying (ASK) (digital AM) in which the amplitude of the carrier wave is modulated in step with the message signal.
Frequency Shift Keying (FSK) (digital FM) in which the frequency of the carrier wave is modulated in step with the message signal.
Phase Shift Keying (PSK) (digital PM) in which the phase of the carrier wave is modulated in step with the message signal.
ASK and PSK may also be used at the same time on one carrier, which is called Quadrature Amplitude Modulation (QAM) or Amplitude/Phase Keying (APK). The receiver is designed to receive the carrier wave, detect these amplitude and phase shifts in the carrier (demodulation), and thus retrieve the digital message.
When a carrier wave is modulated, it is no longer a single frequency but is spread out over a range of frequencies. The bandwidth of the modulated carrier wave is the range from lowest to highest frequency, with the original carrier frequency in the center. The bandwidth is approximately equal to the speed of the digital message, e.g. 10,000 Hz (10 KHz) for voice or 1,000,000 Hz (1 MHz) for video.
OFDM (Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing) is a method of using many carrier waves instead of only one, and using each carrier wave for only part of the message. OFDM is also called multicarrier modulation (MCM) or Discrete Multi-Tone (DMT). We first describe Multiplexing, then Frequency Division and then Orthogonal. It is important to stress that OFDM is not really a modulation scheme since it does not conflict with other modulation schemes. It is more a coding scheme or a transport scheme.
Multiplexing is a way to split a high speed digital message into many lower speed ones. A useful analogy is a highway with a toll collection point. Where each car is one bit of the message, and the number of cars passing a given point in one second is the speed of the message, which represents bits per second. The single lane highway may be split into 10 different lanes for paying tolls. At a point beside the single lane highway, the cars will pass at high speed, whereas at the toll booths, the cars will pass slowly. Thus the single high speed message (flow of cars past a point of single lane highway) is divided into many low speed messages (flow of cars past many toll booths). In a perfect system, the first car will take the first toll lane, the second car takes the second toll lane, etc. The 11th car takes the first toll lane again, and follows the first car. A multiplexer is a switch that assigns each car to one of the many toll booths.
Demultiplexing is the opposite, where many low speed messages are combined into one high speed message. Following the analogy, demultiplexing is where the many low speed messages (cars) passing slowly through the toll booth lanes are merged back into a high speed message traveling quickly on a single lane highway.
Frequency division is where each toll booth lane represents a different carrier frequency or simply the carrier. Orthogonal is a mathematical term used to describe axese and functions that do not influence each other.
Orthogonal Frequency Division
Orthogonal Frequency Division is where the spacing between carriers is equal to the speed (bit rate) of the message (explained in more detail later).
In earlier multiplexing literature, a multiplexer was primarily used to allow many users to share a communications medium like a phone trunk between two telephone central offices. In OFDM, it is typical to assign all carriers to a single user; hence multiplexing is not used with its generic meaning.
Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing is then the concept of typically establishing a communications link using a multitude of carriers each carrying an amount of information identical to the separation between the carriers.
In comparing OFDM and single carrier communication systems (SCCM), the total speed in bits per second is the same for both, 1 Mbit/sec (Mbps) in this example. For single carrier systems, there is one carrier frequency, and the 1 Mbps message is modulated on this carrier, resulting in a 1 MHz bandwidth spread on both sides of the carrier. For OFDM, the 1,000,000 bps message is split into 10 separate messages of 100,000 bit/sec each, with a 100 KHz bandwidth spread on both sides of the carrier.
To illustrate how frequencies change with time, we can use the analogy of the sounds of an orchestra or band. One carrier wave is analogous to one instrument playing one note, whereas many carriers is analogous to many instruments playing at once. Single carrier systems using a high speed message is analogous to a drum roll where the sticks are moving fast. Multicarrier systems (OFDM) using many low speed messages is analogous to many instruments playing more slowly.
A final comparison between OFDM and SCCM is to state that SCCM carry the information is a serial manner whereas OFDM carries the information in a parallel manner.
A more detailed understanding of Orthogonal arises when we observe thatthe bandwidth of a modulated carrier has a so called sinc shape (sinx/x) with nulls spaced by the bit rate. In OFDM, the carriers are spaced at the bit rate, so that the carriers fit in the nulls of the other carriers. Another view of Orthogonal is that each carrier has an integer number of sine wave cycles in one bit period.
How to Implement OFDM?
Original multicarrier systems were implemented through the generation of a number of carriers using separate local oscillators. This was inefficient and costly (though increased the data rate). When a mathematical transform (the fast Fourier transform - FFT) was introduced to generate the different individual carriers and ensure their orthogonality, OFDM was reborn. The FFT basically calculates the spectral content of the signal. It moves a signal from the time domain where it is expressed as a series of time events to the frequency domain where it is expressed as the amplitude and phase of a particular frequency. The inverse FFT (IFFT) performs the reciprocal operation. Data (which can be digitized speech, digitized video or computer data) is coded for security or error correction. It is then modulated by some form of QAM (QAM, 16QAM or 64QAM for example). In single carrier systems, the data would then be placed at the appropriate frequency for transmission. In OFDM, the data is then framed into frames of a suitable size for an FFT. An FFT should be of length 2r (where r is an integer). Not all 2r points in the FFT are used to carry the information; some points are placed for fine-tuning the frequency or for tracking the timing of the bits. An IFFT is performed on the frames. Each frame output from the IFFT is placed at the appropriate frequency for transmission.
In the receiver, the inverse operations are performed and data is recovered. However, as the FFT is performed in the receiver, the data is then in the frequency domain which makes correcting the imperfections of the channel simple.
OFDM was known since the mid 50s. Why OFDM only became popular in 2000 is because economical integrated circuits that can perform a high speed FFT real time were not available until 1998.
Peak-to-Average Ratio (PAR) Problem
A characteristic of FFT is that if the input to it happened to be a sinusoid, the output will be a pulse of height 2r. If the input was a pulse of some height, the output would be a sinusoid of height 1. This means that the output of the FFT has a minimum dynamic range of 10log2r. Dynamic range is a term used to define the linearity requirement of a system. It represents the ability of the system to honestly reproduce the signals input into it. The dynamic range of an OFDM system then is typically larger by as much as two to four times that of a single carrier system. The dynamic range increase leads to an increase in the cost both in terms of dollars and power consumption of the transmitter amplifier. This PAR problem is one of the reasons early high speed OFDM systems were only implemented in broadcasting applications.
Why Use OFDM?
When the radio signals travel from one location to another, they may bounce off surrounding objects (Figure 1), resulting in multiple paths between transmitter and receiver. This is analogous to echoes or reflections causing multiple copies of the message to arrive at the receiver at different times. The combination of all paths at the receiver causes the modulated message signal to be distorted.
A simple example is where there are only two paths, the line of sight path and a reflected path from the ground. If a message is sent at the right speed, then the second (reflected) copy of the message may arrive exactly one bit time later than the first (direct) copy. The receiver will then receive two different bits mixed together, thus distorting the original message bit (Figure 1). Wireless communication systems have to be designed to cope with this so-called multipath distortion.